Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The problem is not any particular "modern" web browser

It is the so-called "modern" web browser itself

For certain users who care about certain things, the concept is fatally flawed

The problem of the so-called "modern" web browser concept is that every computing task ends up "inside the browser" and thus outside the user's control

"Ad blocking" is no exception

Many so-called "modern" browsers now contain their own "ad blockers"

These "ad blockers" are not under the user's control^1. By putting them "inside the browser" the browser vendor has the final control, not the user

These browser vendors are generally seeking to profit from advertising or marketing services

For any user that seeks to avoid internet marketing and advertising, this presents a problem: the user's and the vendor's interests conflict

This is why I could never take Javascript-based "ad blockers" that work "inside the browser" seriously as a long-term solution

I use them, in conjunction with other methods, but I am prepared for them to stop working at any time.^2 I have always relied on programs that are "outside the browser", not under the browser vendor's control

1. In theory, if the browser is "open source", large numbers of users should be able to modify the source code to stop the browser from automatically requesting unwanted ads, tracking and telemetry. In practice, for a variety of reasons, this does not happen. The browser vendors, including Mozilla, make no effort to remove those reasons

2. This includes UBO in Firefox. The question is not if but when



Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: