Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

According to some people on X, they shut down immediately, while rides were still active. Sounds like an unplanned (and quite crazy) action.

https://x.com/gergelyorosz/status/2095256757178188113



Given Uber is one of the few companies who are lucky enough to have a separate page for all the controversies on Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_surrounding_Uber), they also have their own fair of experience with police raids on their offices. They've also used "‘kill switch’ during raids to stop police seeing data" (https://www.theguardian.com/news/2022/jul/10/uber-files-leak...) before, so I wouldn't be surprised if this was some sort of legal "kill switch" or whatever that got triggered, so they can get rid of everything faster.


> They've also used "‘kill switch’ during raids to stop police seeing data

If Uber wasn't a VC backed company, they would have been charged with destruction of evidence or similar.


They likely were but Companies don't go to jail they pay fines


Shops and factories can be temporarily shut down if they don't comply with regulations. Businesses that require licenses like law practices may similarly have to stop operations. That is half of going to jail.

Unfortunately, the growth potential that software industry generally provides has generally prevented governments for creating and enforcing similar laws for software products and such.


How does growth potential relate to legal enforcement?


In the current system, political parties who do things that stop the economy growing are usually voted out, more than political parties that refuse to take action against nebulous criminal activity. That's why, for example, my city refuses to do anything to stop the factories in the city from dumping waste into the river.


The way everybody involved makes money


In the US, "printing money" is the most sacred act there is. If you're doing that, laws suddenly don't apply.


Various Uber city team managers have spent time in jail.


Unless you throw the investors and senior executives in jail how do you intend to do anything more than performative dance with these measures.

I personally think countries should start sanctioning and international warrants for all large investors and senior executives in a company if something like this happens.

But it won't happen unless US changes their stance on companies being liability shiled.

Sure it should require very exceptional cases but I know companies whose negligence has cost lives of hundreds of people, the reason they and all their investors weren't jailed is the real scam of the democraciez we have gifted ourselves.


That sort of thing is called a sacrificial pawn.


The manager of Uber Paris was jailed for just that.


In some african countries getting the permanent full attention of the law is the equivalent of punishment for not paying bribes.

You pay the "extra" or you spend 8h at the police station waiting to be processed. To get raided by police in a corrupt country is the highest moral praise you get for playing it by yhe book .


It was planned. What's Nigeria and Uganda gonna do?


This is hilarious. They are legally kidnappers at this point. No reason to even stop the ride and let you get out for free.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: