Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Your website seems to conflate "Europe" with the EU.

Can you clarify, here and on the website, whether the data remains:

* in _EU member state_ sovereign territory

* in _European states'_ sovereign territory

* on the contentinent of Europe

or some combination of the above?

I am specifically wondering about:

* Out-of-Europe territories of European states.

* UK, Norway, Russia, Switzerland, Serbia etc.

 help



In Europe people generally use “Europe” and the EU interchangeably.

I’m not sure many people would include Russia in Europe in normal speech, unless they were a geographer in which case Russia is partly “Europe” in some cases I think.

Even when the UK was part of the EU if someone in the UK said “Europe” they meant continental Europe and someone in continental Europe would be unlikely to mean the UK if they said Europe unless they were using “Europe” as a shorthand for the EU. When the UK was in the EU a United States American saying Europe would probably not not be including the UK in their mental model of Europe and, indeed [0], might not be very clear on what the UK actually is, because that’s confusing for the countries they agglomerate into “England” which might also include Ireland. A United States American saying “Europe” most likely means “Paris” and then maybe France, Italy, Spain or Greece but probably not Germany which is definitely the EU and everything that is wrong with the EU. But maybe Switzerland, because that very European.

As a European I’m not even sure where Serbia is, or if it’s even a real country [1]. I thought it was capital of Albania [2] . Or possibly a region of North Macedonia [3]

[0] only some of what I have said should be taken even part way seriously. Very little in fact

[1] Obviously being satirical here

[2,3] Also real countries, also European, but not necessarily “Europe” and definitely not EU. Yet.


> In Europe people generally use “Europe” and the EU interchangeably.

In Europe some people generally and incorrectly use "Europe" and the EU interchangeably. Europe existed far before the EU and will continue to exist after the EU finally comes to an end.


> Europe existed far before the EU and will continue to exist after the EU finally comes to an end.

First clause: indisputable.

Second clause: maybe, maybe not. Europe hasn't always existed as a concept, and its longevity is unknown.


> Europe hasn't always existed as a concept, and its longevity is unknown.

Europe is the name of a continent. What reason(s) would there be to change the name of a continent?

In contrast, the EU is a trading block, set up to foster greater pan-European trading relations. It's not the only pan-European institution. For example, the Council of Europe ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Europe ) is a separate pan-European institution, set up in 1946 which was before the EU or any of the predecessors of the EU, and amongst other projects was behind the formation of the European Court of Human Rights. I bring this up to highlight that we do not need the EU in order to have collaboration between European countries.


Do you think the Egyptians called it Europe?

When do you think people began calling "America" "America", and why? Or referring to the largest continent as "Africa" ?

I understand what your point was. I was thinking long term and noting that the future is uncertain, at best.


> Do you think the Egyptians called it Europe?

You haven't given any dates, but if you're talking about ancient Egypt, i.e. the Egypt before 0AD, then yes. The term "Europa" was used to refer to the continent around this time by the Greeks, and I don't see why Egyptian people wouldn't have picked up on a useful term they didn't have before.


I think you maybe missed my footnotes.

Even if you did/did not, vernacular evolves. So at the time that you fervently hope the EU comes to its (clearly deserved, Mr Putin) end, I imagine people will be able to adapt their wrong speak and clearly incorrect thinking to ensure they adhere to the newspeak.


> at the time that you fervently hope the EU comes to its (clearly deserved, Mr Putin) end

I find it funny you think the only reason people would want the end of the EU is if they're a Russian agent. The EU has very little to do with defence. Perhaps your argument would hold more weight if talking about NATO, but even then it's not necessary for countries to be members of NATO in order to collaborate on protection when their collective security interests align.


Well, there are other reasons. For instance if they've been influenced by Russian agents trying to sow discord.

Haha, got to be the Russians right, EU is clearly beyond valid criticism. /s

I’m sure many thought the same about the United States of America when it was founded.

I guess the difference is the founding of the EU didn’t require multiple genocidal slaughters.

Oh, wait.


This only matters to people outside the EU. Since most of Europe is in or deliberately out. It’s hard to care too much about that.

> In Europe people generally use “Europe” and the EU interchangeably.

I guess you don't wander out of your office in Brussels much.


Oh sweetheart. The real looney Eurocrats like us don’t even leave Strasbourg. Brussels is filthy.

« As a European I’m » – So what country do you hail from? I understand it's not Serbia. Just so this wild nonsense and wannabe satire can have proper geographic attribution. (Because despite there being a strong indidivual factor, the systems governing some countries do breed certain mental dispositions.)

[flagged]


OK! Your generalisation definitely beats mine.

The FAQ seems clear on this

> Where is my code actually hosted?

> On bare-metal servers that we operate in Scaleway's Paris datacenters


That could change at any time. They could move to an Italy datacenter owned by a different company and that would be just fine.

But whether they're making a promise to stay in the EU specifically? Or whether they might expand to territories that aren't physically in Europe? That could matter, and the FAQ doesn't tell us.

(And yeah the line at the top says 100% EU but that's not the full picture.)


I hope they also have a backup outside Paris.

From the website:

"Your repos never leave the EU"

That's clear enough I think.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: