Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I never found a piece of text that pangram claims is 100% AI that to me seems like purely human written text.

That's another claim you made, which is quite silly. You've never found something that Pangram marks as 0% human and which you deem to be 100% human? Huge gulf.

And no, not really. It's copy from fundraising materials. Removing the identifiable portions of it would remove virtually everything, which is perhaps why Pangram didn't flag it?



I said it wasn't something I wanted to read. Humans are capable of writing things I don't want to read. Which at this point is starting to include your comments.


Did you not write the quoted text?


I did and it's true, but I amended my statement at the top of this thread, which you've ignored.

What I wrote is true (it is a claim about my experience), so I'm not sure what you're attacking.

I amended my statement to avoid a discussion about the provenance which is not what I actually care about. What I care about is if I want to read it. Humans could theoretically write something in AI voice and if they did, I wouldn't want to read it.

I have not seen any examples of human text in LLM style that clearly predate 2023. If you can supply one, that would be incredible evidence.

If you're able to supply a prompt which generates text that fools pangram and is not like one sentence long or a list of names or something, but actual prose I want to read, then I will concede.


Oh, well sure, but I don't care about your preferences for what you'd like to read. You can use a Ouija board to decide whether something is worth reading for all I care, just don't use it to accuse other people of plagiarism or dishonesty.

Duh.

If your statement was "my super special dowsing rods tell me what I want to read with 100% accuracy" I'd say "cool." But that wasn't your claim.

> If you're able to supply a prompt which generates text that fools pangram and is not like one sentence long or a list of names or something, but actual prose I want to read, then I will concede.

This is an even more conservative claim than the one you just made! Sheesh.

Have a good day.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: