Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes I trust this government with that power. /extreme sarcasm
 help



Yes I trust sama/dario/elon with that power

/even more extreme sarcasm than you


I don't trust them, which is why I inherently question the validity of their RSI/bioweapon/extinction claims.

You trust trump more than any of those three? Really?

You can have an arbitrarily low opinion of Trump and still trust in democracy as a form of government over autocracy or oligarchy, which is what the AI labs have.

You can have abstract trust in democracy over autocracy, but this is not an abstract question - these are the actual choices. Does it really matter if the person who will use AI to fuck us has a "democratic mandate" to do so? We're fucked either way.

It's less the mandate that matters, but the fact that they can be removed from power.

You don't speak for anybody outside of your borders, so please stop trying to.

The majority of the world will refuse to be subject to American AI laws under the control of the US gov't, whether it pretends to be democratic or not. Or should.


> You don't speak for anybody outside of your borders, so please stop trying to.

FWIW, I'm not American and refuse to step foot within American borders while Trump is in power.


Exactly. No matter how bad Trump is, millions of American people at least voted / vouched for him. Nobody voted for Elon Musk, Sam Altman, or any other CEO to have as much power as they have. Maybe a handful of shareholders. Totally unelected and unapproved by the public, but run companies that affect most of the public's lives.

That's an extremely fair objection! But despite the many, many flaws of our government and the current administration, I still have (hopefully) a chance to vote them out of power. I have no such hopes with Sam Altman or Elon Musk.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: