In fact, if your brain were removed from your body, and you were locked in a room that was completely empty and precisely calibrated to your brain's ambient temperature, and you were then ordered on your life to not ruminate. Well -- I would posit that you wouldn't last very long.
There's something else going on with human cognition -- and reasoning by extension -- that LLMs are, to date, not replicating.
With the big caveat of AFAIK. I'm not in one of the labs close to this stuff.
> Not really. Noone has to prompt you to ruminate.
Why do the internal mechanics need to mirror how it works in humans?
I have agents that receive sensory input (video/audio) which run continuously processing it, receiving events as they occur. When something strange happens they notice and take action (i.e. there's an unrecognized person in the living room -> ask who they are.)
Presumably you've seen the agents that play video games - build things to progress in Minecraft, plan routes, avoid adversaries, etc.
Why doesn't that count?
I feel like you're failing to consider anything outside the chatbot UI.
EDIT: The first morning my agents had access to an outside video stream they commented on the sunrise. While I was sleeping through it.
> they are incapable ... of independently starting a reasoning task.
I have provided several examples of them independently starting reasoning tasks.
... and I'm wondering why you seem to be entirely unaware of such examples. The most likely explanation being you are only aware of the chat interface.
... and I have absolutely no idea of what you mean by "... and feel".
In fact, if your brain were removed from your body, and you were locked in a room that was completely empty and precisely calibrated to your brain's ambient temperature, and you were then ordered on your life to not ruminate. Well -- I would posit that you wouldn't last very long.
There's something else going on with human cognition -- and reasoning by extension -- that LLMs are, to date, not replicating.
With the big caveat of AFAIK. I'm not in one of the labs close to this stuff.