Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why are you sure it's really helpful for some people?

Before psychology you had religion, even in the oldest form of Christianity, orthodoxy, you are not too dwell on the past, not to blaim others.

I doubt it really truly helps anyone to dig up the past

 help



Logged in just to say, for me reaching into my past has been one of the most transformative and healing acts I've ever done.

I have a friend, next alcoholic, she was recently reading through her old journals to try to figure out her life. What happened? She told me that she had a really strong impulse to start drinking again.

In my opinion, you gain nothing from looking at trauma or trying to see some psychological way to get out of it. The only cure is to forget about it.


Extrapolating from a single anecdote seems like poor judgment.

Why is this complicated? If you can’t remember the trauma, how can you suffer from it?

Now we may have behaviors that were shaped by our trauma, but remembering our trauma, what does that do but reinforce the memory again and there force reinforce our trauma response?

All that has to be done is focus on your present date and your present reaction examine if that’s dysfunctional or not.


>Why is this complicated? If you can’t remember the trauma, how can you suffer from it?

Because trauma affixes neutal pathways. You don't have to remember it to be affected, at all.


If you find a bug in your code does it matter who is to blame? Is it useful to remember you had a fight with your wife the day you committed it?

Does a car mechanic need a video of the crash to fix the car?


The correct analogy here would be that if you notice your program repeatedly acting incorrectly in the same way, you trace the execution path.

Past trauma can often be the root.

Failing to recognize it and reprogram that part of your brain leads to patching over symptoms, which... causes other issues.

Where this breaks down for some people -- not everyone has trauma, or at least severe enough trauma to need to deal with it.

Some people act like assholes because they were hurt when they were young. Others act like assholes because that's just how they decided to act.


The human brain is neither computer nor automobile.

> If you find a bug in your code does it matter who is to blame?

If you want to fix the code, you need to go to the right line.


How much of that is pseudoscience?

None of it, this has been common knowledge for decades.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6428430/

https://aifs.gov.au/resources/practice-guides/effect-trauma-...

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3968319/

Adding to this, trauma extends to multiple generations:

"Intergenerational influences of paternal combat-related trauma on offspring behavioral and brain function"

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S235228952...

"Exposure of Men to PTSD-Promoting Trauma Elevates Levels of Sperm miRNAs with Anxiety and Depression-Inducing Activities"

https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.04.22.720211v1...


Combined with N<20 and a definition of trauma that means literally any experience, we might be able to get a preprint published claiming trauma cures cancer as well.

It really depends. If those are your best memories, sure - that works and actually helps to even go back to things you enjoyed as a teen - this btw, has been as an positive example for people that struggle with depression.

But if those are destructive memories, that you want to return to and that are at the base of your misery, then no - that is absolutely worst thing to return to, as there is nothing you can change there and the things that are affecting you are coming from that already. So, pretty much this is the reason why it is important for kids to have stable normal life.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: