Maybe, but it still there and probably has a different value between distros as well. Default value is 60, what is that good for exactly?
If you're in a position where you still want swap to be there, but only used in extreme situations, then you should set it yourself. Otherwise disable swap or switch a language.
What do you think this value of 60 means? Also, as I said, in extreme situations, when the system is right before invoking the OOM killer, swap is used regardless of `vm.swappiness` setting.
Value 60 is not an arbitrary number. It makes the kernel reclaim 140 file pages for each 60 swapped-out anon pages. This proportion is supposed to reflect the relative performance cost between sequential file access and random swap I/O on HDD. For SSDs, the value 100 is more appropriate.
> I don't see a reason why the default shouldn't be 0 then on modern systems.
The zero value makes reclaim very unbalanced and is not appropriate for generic systems. This will cause the kernel to discard all the page cache, slowing down the system with uncached I/O, while keeping all unused anonymous pages in memory.
I don't get the point that you're even arguing. Are you saying that 60 is fine as a default? Or are you saying that people should even think about vm.swappiness because it doesn't matter? The alternative here is to disable swap completely, that's what started this whole thread.
