Except that wasn’t all I said. This is not a court case, I don’t have to go into details on why I have that opinion. Comments are just comments, you don’t have to say more than what impressions you had of the article. There was also no implication of moral or intellectual superiority, you’re projecting your own dim view of why someone might criticize an article. Just because I found the author’s claim unconvincing doesn’t mean I think I’m better than him. It takes a lot of arrogance to assume that’s why I said what I said, which is to say, you’re projecting your own arrogance onto me. Everyone in the world doesn’t share your (lack of) morals.