Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Leave him alone in a room with a computer..."

I prefer to leave them alone in a room with only pencil and paper. I want to see every piece of paper when I return, including diagrams, notes, and most of all, the entire audit trail of what they did (cross outs, revisions, etc.) I don't care how it looks or how well it compiles or runs. What I really care about is the thought process they went through. Pencil and paper shows me that much better.



Am I the only person who gets insane cramp when having to write a lot on paper? Unless i've only got to write one short function i'm gonna be screwed up by your test.


"...i'm gonna be screwed up by your test..."

That's exactly what I want to see. I don't care how well you type or how well you navigate an IDE. I care how well you think and approach an unstructured problem under pressure in an unfamiliar environment.

(FWIW, I would never give a problem whose solution would require more than 30 to 50 lines of code. Lots of people would put in one line for the function and then explain the function to me later. No one has ever complained about cramping. You're the first.)


He's talking about being screwed up by the manual writing process.


You could put some screen recording software on the computer. Of course it would be nice to tell them about it in advance.


Or perhaps ask them to use version control and check in the code after each little step of the design or development.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: