Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is exactly what we knew would happen. Apple is not our friend. They are at best an ally, and at worst prepared to destroy an industry for the sake of profit and domination.


"They are at best an ally, and at worst prepared to destroy an industry for the sake of profit and domination."

This is everybody in the industry. Convince yourself otherwise at your own peril.


This is everybody in the industry. Convince yourself otherwise at your own peril.

Really? Even open source projects? Or let me guess, you'd argue that open source projects aren't part of the "industry".


Well, if RMS and similar zealots could have their way, they would have crushed the software industry for the sake of OSS/GNU domination. If he could influence policy, for example, he'd probably try to ban proprietary software.

And if you think that's beneficial, well, I for one would rather keep my Premiere and Logic and the (dongle locked) Reason, than just be forced to use the crappy open source alternatives out there.


People who want good software would find a way to make it and pay for it even if proprietary software were outlawed (which I don't think is a good idea, for the record).


Corporate-sponsored open source is very much part of the industry, often more so than closed source projects due to ubiquity.


Yeah, but is a bit different when you are so big that you crush everywhere you walk.


I'd hardly call taking down a website "destroying an industry for profit and domination". The OpenNI Framework source code isn't going to disappear.


The framework source code is not the important part -- it's just dumb plumbing and glue. The tracking code (NITE) is what's important. It is not open source at all -- merely freely available. (All you can get are the compiled libraries.) As far as I know, this is the only freely available, full body skeleton tracker that works on Linux.


Does OpenNI even have non-skeletal blob tracking on its own, or is NITE required for that as well?


This. For some, this is SO hard to understand.


You could make that argument about any company.


Like Mozilla? Cloudera? any other open-source company? I know hyperbolic statements are fashionable, but this one isn't really true.


While other companies like Google are truly our friends. They are a public company, not a non-profit.


>They are at best an ally, and at worst prepared to destroy an industry for the sake of profit and domination.

You mean the iOS app industry that they created out of thin air themselves, offering the platform, an API, and a far better environment (and terms) than the god awful Java ME stores of the past?


What does OpenNI and desktop augmented reality apps have to do with the iOS app industry?


Why, did parent talked specifically about the augmented reality apps industry, or used the OpenNI to make a general point about how Apple would crush the independent app industry for profit?


No for profit company is your friend.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: