Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think a lot of people may not realize how cheap this is. 700 credits is effectively $20, because you get 500 free credits for signing up, and additional credits only cost 10 cents.


Did you wear that Armani coat on sales calls or to raise money?


I think I did wear it when we were visiting galleries for Artix, the horrible startup we tried before Viaweb, because I found a couple Artix business cards in the pocket.


You should include those Business cards with the coat :-)


As the proud new owner of pg's old coat, I wouldn't say no to that.


how about a cashmere sweater ?

http://www.listia.com/auction/208


Heh.. How about Dracula cape!?

(I saw it in the previous announcement, http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=743881)

Ed: Also PG could clarify what he scribbled on there.. http://c0139491.cdn.cloudfiles.rackspacecloud.com/photos/231... I deciphered only 8 first characters from the first line (Happy ha*); also, G in PG looks exactly like my handwritten &, which is lovely, but nobody will believe me I haven't forged that.


Happy hacking!


It is cheap, on ebay the unsigned version goes for $85. (I checked ;) ).


I got the HDTV for $80 and some crap that I gave away, which makes Listia my favorite YC startup ever.


I want this, but when I signed up I only got 100 credits. I sent them an email.


To get more credits you're supposed to list stuff and use the site (on the premise that you will use it more in the future if you've used it once before).

But don't bother, see above.


That sounds like a bug.


If so, it's an unfortunate one, because it looks identical to a common bait-and-switch. The pre-signup copy reads "Get 500 free credits \n Earn more by referring friends, listing auctions, or buying them ($0.10 each)" After signup, you have 100 credits, and the site copy reads something like "list something to get the rest of your 500 credits". Get on this, guys.


sorry about the wording. It's clear in all the FAQ and about pages, but I guess we ran out of real estate where some of the text is shorter. Will get right on this.


Dear modsearch, you guys have the right idea but the wrong way of implementing it.

My advice would be really short and simple:

stop.

You can launch exactly once. It doesn't matter if you are feature complete. But it does matter if you're consistent.

You are building an e-commerce site of sorts, so reputation is really your only real currency. The site right now is confusing.

Fix it! Now. Don't promote it any further than it has gone already, repair those things, make it clear and consistent and then make your push.

Also, you should probably yank all the dummy auctions (or at least the stuff that looks like a dummy auction) (a poorly drawn giraffe ? a floppy disk ?) because they degrade the profile of your site.

I realize you guys are of good intentions but you are making a poor first impression. You only get one chance at a first impression.


We will implement consistency fixes asap. However, I don't think there are any more giraffes on there :) all the auctions on there are from real users and we try our best to moderate the fake or silly ones :)


Good one.

Let me know when you're done I'll give you a boost, email is in the 'about' bit.

I've been hard enough on you ;)


No, your feedback has been great. We need to think about these things and we're glad you brought them up. Thanks!


In addition to the other text I quoted, you should probably change this: "1. Sign up and get 500 free credits"


You have to sign up and list a item to get 500, if I understand correctly.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: