Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is a solution desperately searching for a problem. Exactly what Steve Jobs warned against in developing technology.

I personally can't care less about modularity in a phone. Would rather have a 1mm thinner phone over any sort of modularity. Almost all modules can be added wirelessly, unless they are latency-sensitive or very high bandwidth.

Additionally, due to economies of scale, it may make sense to integrate a module that's extremely useful to only a half of the population in every device manufactured and that may still be a net win economically.



Just like there are iMacs and custom built desktop PCs, more choice is good for everyone


Good for everyone, ...except Google shareholders maybe? (Maybe not though; it might earn more for them in marketing value, as Satya Nadella pointed out.)


You really going to try to bring in the guy who said that small tablets and large phones were a non-starter? Today? Without irony?


The guy who built the company with the largest market cap in the US and the phone I am using today and is still my favorite gadget, yes.

Who he is is of little relevance here, by the way. I am not appealing to his authority. I'm simply citing the most prolific source of this mindset I know of to make the concept I am talking about clearer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: