Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't know if the comment was edited or not, but I hope you're not claiming "vigilante" is a slur. I looked up the definition of slur just to be sure and you are technically correct, but I'd say you're abusing language far more than the person you're responding to.


It said "Karen" and the commenter edited it.

Edit: I've added the context back by quoting what the GP originally said. I guess one good passive-aggressive stealth edit deserves another.


Sorry, "passive-aggressive stealth edit"? You got what you wanted. They took out the mean word. Don't get pissy about it and start gaslighting people.


Editing a comment after the fact in a way that deprives a reply of its original context and makes it look stupid is, in most cases, a dick move. I think most users understand that. It doesn't make a difference whether the reply was by a moderator or not.


- Accusing a user of using a slur

- Getting snarky because they did the reasonable thing and got rid of the slur after it was pointed out

- Calling said user a dick. If Karen is a misogynistic slur, How is dick not moreso misandristic? I realize you said "dick move", but that's functionally the same. Saying something was a "c?nt move" or a "n????r move" would be tantamount to calling someone a c?nt or n????r.

- Because maybe it made your comment "look stupid"

Jawdropping desecration of the guidelines. You need a vacation.


It would be nice if there was a way to display text in a strikethrough font.

Though, in this specific context, appending something like "Edit: 's/Karens/vigilantes/g'" would be the unambiguous way to document the edit.


In most of the spaces I frequent, an edit to change objectionable wording after being called on it is acceptable. Since you've made it plain that that sort of approach doesn't work here, I'll keep that in mind.


Thanks!


Also, that's the user dang. He pretty much runs HN. I'd assume anything he says in these regards as fact and trust him.


I certainly hope not. People need to push back when we get things wrong. Luckily for me they are not shy about doing so.


This comment is what leadership looks like.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: