Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes

BUT it's also a form of "insurance". If there's a suspect a bank won't be able to honor deposits, bank run ensues, THEN the given bank can't honor deposits obviously, because no bank works like that today, that is: self fulfilling prophecy

It's a necessary evil (for the customer's sake)



If you don't trust the bank, don't put your money there. Otherwise, put your money at the Bank of the United States, backed by and owned by the full faith of the US taxpayer.

I will not bail out private money making banks via the FDIC via my tax dollar.

If you put money into a private bank, then when it fails, you should lose that money.


I will not bail out private money making banks via the FDIC via my tax dollar.

Never in American history has the FDIC had to take a "tax dollar" during a bank failure. The government does back it, yes--but the amount of private money in the FDIC makes it extremely unlikely that bank failures even at the scope we were looking at in 2008 will tap them out.


Credit unions don't participate in FDIC insurance, they have arranged their own private insurance. So it is not a necessary evil.


Credit unions participate in the NCUA, which is decidedly not private.

http://www.ncua.gov/Pages/default.aspx


Sorry, you are right, I didn't realize it was a federal agency, I thought it was something they had arranged amongst themselves.


Insurance is a necessary evil, if it's backed by the government or by a pool of banks is a different issue




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: