Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To be fair, Google respects robots.txt (and the atrocious "right to be forgotten"), and they won't stop you from using GMail if you encrypt everything with PGP. Unlike others (cough-Facebook-cough), they usually don't feel the need to trick users into sharing more than they'd want. The classic "if you've done nothing wrong" attitude is more a personal opinion of certain individuals (a certain Eric Schmidt comes to mind) than intrinsic to Google culture. So I don't think you're being fair here; it's not like they actively try to distribute salary details of all other companies...


> they usually don't feel the need to trick users into sharing more than they'd want

Like the time they didn't feel the need to harass everyone into signing up for G+ any time one used an unrelated service?


No, not like that. How did you determine that sharing more than you want was like getting you to sign up for a service?


When one signs up for G+, their G+ profile (containing information about them) becomes public. It is easy to rush through the setup process, especially when one did not desire to go through it, and accidentally share more information than desired.


That's totally different, antsar. I'm 95% sure the motive for that was to simply grow the user base of G+ and try to get more people to know that the platform even exists.


That probably was the motive. But the side effect is that now people have public G+ profiles which they may not have wanted, sharing information about them (even as simple as their name and photo) that they would rather keep private.


> To be fair, Google respects robots.txt

Not all of their crawlers respect robots.txt


Do you have an example? A crawler ignoring robots.txt sounds like a bug, and if you have details I can file a bug with the appropriate team.


FeedFetcher User Agent




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: